Party Supply Stores in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn 11209
The Party Fair store on 20th Avenue closed ,so everyone has asked me where can they can find party supplies in Bay Ridge?
Here are some other party goods stores:
1) Party Plan It at 8414 – 5th Avenue Brooklyn 11209 718-836-3701 Great place for helium balloons – large selection and the number balloons too. He has more balloons than are shown on the walls. . Mark, the owner did a beautiful job with balloons for a baby shower I was giving. He arrived and set them up before I came (and I was early). The tables looked beautiful– exactly as I requested.
2) Party Color Store at 7624 – 5th Avenue Brooklyn 11209 718-765-1555 They have clear bags for favors/goodies.
3) Reyes Creations is at 6929 3rd Avenue (used to be across from Keyfood at 241 Bay Ridge Avenue) They sell Disney Party items – small store, but they have a lot of items and good flowers – see pictures.
4) Party City closed at 625 Atlantic Avenue, but in the Fall of 2025, they opened in the basement of Staples on 5th Avenue and 94th Street. There is a parking lot here.
Dollar Stores that have Party Supplies
- 99 Cents Store and Up on 4th Avenue and 95th Street across the street from St. Pats Church – 99 cent helium balloons – super nice
- Apple 99 Cents Store – 8104 – 5th Avenue has good party section (some things more than $1) usually open to 9 pm.
- City 99 Cents Store – 5th Avenue between 86th and 87th (many things are $1.29) – closer to 87th Street – Pizza Wagon is on this block
- DII Discount Store – 8701 – 4th Avenue – huge cheap store on the corner of 87th Street – neon plates, cheap plain kids t-shirts for decorating
- 99 Cents Store – 66th Street and 18th Avenue – great 99 cents store – cheap helium balloons – a few stores away from DaVinci Pizza -Party Ville is a Hallmark type stores and they have the over sized balloons
- 111 NY 99 Cents Store 8402 18th Avenue Brooklyn 11214 – huge 99 cents store
- Super Feng Discount – 2235 86th Street Brooklyn 11214 – near Bay 31st Street…..a friend of mine always says she gets things here!
- 99 Cents store – Bay Parkway and 72nd Street
- Dollar Tree at 590 Hamilton Ave, Brooklyn, New York 11232 has helium balloons and party goods for cheap prices.
Walgreens on 3rd Avenue and 95th Street has some helium balloons.
Duane Reade on 86st Street sells helium balloon.
Other stores with Party Supplies
- Deals 2402 86th Street Brooklyn 11214 718-266-1471 Has helium balloons – open to 9pm
- Amazing Savings 1415 Ave M Brooklyn 11230 (Midwood)
- Michaels Craft Store 410 Gateway Dr Brooklyn 11239 347-694-4067
- Target – 519 Gateway Drive Brooklyn 11239, also one on Flatbush Ave
- Party City – 625 Atlantic Avenue Brooklyn 11217 718-399-7252
- Five Below – at Erskine – small toys – good for the goody bag
BJs sells helium tanks for $26.99
Hugs,
marlene
Topics: Bay Ridge | No Comments »