February 1, 2020

Heart Shaped Pizza in Bay Ridge for V-Day

Where can I get a heart shaped pizza in Bay Ridge?

Bklyn Pizza made the pizza above. 1406 86th Street   718-210-9632  $16 for cheese   $19 with pepperoni




Nonno’s Pizzeria made the pizza above – 8816 3rd Avenue  718-238-6200   $17.00   



Bay Ridge made the pizza below. 7704 5th Avenue  718-680-5405 – $21 for large 





Lombardo’s Pizza – 279 71st Street (pickup only between 3-5 pm because they are doing dine-in restaurant for the evening.)  718-238-7100. Their regular pie is  $23     With pepperoni it is – $28






Peppino’s Pizzeria 7708 3rd Avenue  718-238-2527   $18 cash ($20.31 if with card) – they deliver




Rocco’s Pizzeria 7818 5th Avenue  718-238-7658  – $17.99 sign in window




Rocco’s also has a dessert pizza – nutella and strawberries




Brooklyn Firefly 7003 3rd Avenue   718-833-5000  $18 plus tax

Mancini’s Pizzeria ~ 718-333-5209  $16.28




Mancini’s Dessert Heart Pizza $27.15   718-333-5209  





Patsy’s Pizzeria – 8814 3rd Avenue   718-745-3003  






Leo’s Pizza (formerly Leo’s Casa Calamari before he moved)



Mia’s Pizzeria- 18th Avenue 

La Vila Pizzeria – 86th Street    718-256-3100





Johnny’s Pizzeria at 5806 5th Avenue in Sunset Park (but they will deliver to Bay Ridge) 718-492-9735






What if you just want a small heart pizza?

Bay Ridge Pizza makes a small Valentine pie.   7704 5th Avenue  718-680-5405


Campania 9824 4th Avenue  347-517-4868   just posted this one in February 2019



They also posted this one on 2/12/19:



Pizza DAmore on Cesar’s Bay 8949 Bay Pkwy  makes a  personal/mini heart pizza.





On Seamless, Papa John’s put a 12 inch heart pizza for $14.99 – see here     1654 86th Street   929-381-0975

You may be thinking “Oh hell no – not Papa’s”  But if you are in a jam, you might need Papa Johns because a lot of these pizzerias took preorders all day. Or you might now be in the mood to talk to someone so you could just use seamless.  <Wink> 

Next year the other heart dinner items like:


B&A Pork Store Heart Hamburgers:



Heart Ravioli from Patsys.

Heart Shaped Bagels





Topics: Bay Ridge | No Comments »