December 5, 2019

Christmas Eve Feast of the Fishes – Restaurants & Catering



Everyone knows a Brooklyn Nonna that made a traditional Italian Christmas Eve Dinner in Brooklyn, also known as the Feast of the Fishes. Now times are different and both parents work, so there isn’t all this down time to shop and prepare for the holiday. Who caters the Feast of the Fishes in Bay Ridge or nearby in Brooklyn?



  • Tomasso’s  – 1464 – 86th Street.   $65 a person – Also a la carte itemssee here




  • Cebu  8801 3rd Avenue   718-492-5095    They also do catering. The pic below was from the Feast of 7 Fishes last year.


  • C&C Catering  at 7719 – 18th Avenue caters Christmas Eve for $25.95 a person – see here   718-232-2800.    They also have a catering room.   





  • Bassetts at 1404 – Avenue X has a deluxe hot menu (scroll past the basic as there aren’t enough fish dishes on there)      718-332-9000 



  • Il Fornetto’s Restaurant – see menu here.   $46.95 for the prix fix seven fishes meal. $19.95 for a an Italian meal for children






Catering for the Feast of the Seven Fishes


  • La Bellawe started to use them last year and the food was fantastic, no hassle, easy pickup at 7907 13th Avenue.  I made some of the fish, but got some trays from La Bella. Everyone kept asking me where the food was from. The clams were great!






  • ALC Italian Grocery 8613 3rd Avenue – Get some things from here – you won’t regret it.  See their full menu here


  •  Pastosa 7425 New Utrecht Avenue has great food catering menu is on page 2 here (Also on Avenue N)


  • Meats Supreme    1949 – 86th Street   Good for extra trays of hot food



  • Foodtown in Bay Ridge:    Place you Seafood Orders early and avoid the rush..




  • Other restaurants open on Christmas Eve in Bay Ridge – see here






Topics: Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, Dyker Heights | No Comments »